Questria: Princess Destiny Update

Many of you may be wondering why things have been quiet in the past few weeks. I have been hashing out the details of the project to a legal firm (Randazza Legal Group, well known for copyright & 1st amendment and copyright cases). This was due to a large vocal concern on the parody and legal matters inherit in the parody elements of the project. There is bad news that is really just good news. I got a large opinion piece bu I’ve snipped out the most important part.

 

    On the whole, we believe that theoretically, the development of the Questria video game should rightfully support a finding of Fair Use. Unfortunately, I believe that the weight of legal precedent would tilt against a finding of Fair Use, and that if the copyright owners of My Little Pony were to sue, they would prevail.There is transformative use of the My Little Pony series. However, the video game also borrows protectable elements of the original work and is not, at least as presently conceived, a parody of My Little Pony. One of the challenges in a Fair Use case is that Fair User rulings are highly unpredictable, and based on experience, it has taken discovery and some degree of factual development before courts will be comfortable granting summary judgment on a Fair Use defense. There does appear to be a trend in the law that courts are increasingly comfortable granting Fair Use on a limited record.Nevertheless, given the rulings in Re (JK Rowling) and Castle Rock cases, I believe that a Fair Use defense would have a less than 50% chance of success.

This is not to say that is would be hopeless, but I would be certain that you have adequate insurance policies in place to defend you in the case of an infringement claim. Alternatively, we could increase your likelihood of successfully employing a Fair Use before by increasing the level of critique of the original, as well as other elements of the proposed game. Somewhat illogically, the less subtle the reference to the original, the stronger the Fair Use defense.

Accordingly, you may wish to add some conceptual elements to the game that make fun of the original more, or that make a true critique thereof. (1)

(1)Legal Oppinion provided by Randazza Legal Group 

“We are highly experienced in the confluence of First Amendment law and intellectual property law. We have handled complex and high profile matters in both areas, and often are brought in by other law firms seeking a highly specialized eye on these matters.” – Marc John Randazza

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marc_Randazza
https://www.randazza.com/

 

Questria is hitting most transformative bases but the most important one; commentary. This means we are not making enough of a statement on the show, its premise, the fans or any other elements from the my little pony universe. The apple.mov series is protected under parody because it uses the style of the show to make a point about the show. Questria in its current form does not.

“Somewhat illogically, the less subtle the reference to the original, the stronger the Fair Use defense.”


Considering this legal advice; 
Questria: Princess Destiny will now employ humor and make commentary based on the brony culture and My Little Pony to be considered under Fair Use. This would thrust the game into the same level of commentary that you have been accustomed to with Spaceballs, Garbage Pail Kids, Mad Magazine and EgoRaptor cartoons.

The project is very near funding end, final funding cost it is still possible! That said, alternatives to fully funded project will be discussed once the project expires;   will want to hear from all of you on how to proceed forward on future projects.

Thanks for supporting Questria: Princess Destiny!

10 Responses to Questria: Princess Destiny Update

  1. Florentine says:

    Aww..

    That’s really a shame, I much preferred the idea when it was.. I don’t know, sincere feels like it isn’t the best word since I’m sure it still is, but all the same it’s the best I can come up with.

    Still, it remains a worthwhile project so my pledge’ll be staying. Keep it up.

  2. FirestormDDash says:

    I see your schwartz is as big as mine.

  3. Jonathan Duncan says:

    I really enjoyed the simple straight forward game play from the original Princess Maker games, something you could tap a little bit everyday when you got home from work or school, something you could put a little bit of effort into every day and eventually meet some sort of goal.
    What I was hoping to see from the Questria project was something that was simple game play, cute graphics, but still had a lot of depth in terms of what the games story is trying to employ. Which I guess was something similar to training Twilight Sparkle to become a princess.
    I don’t know how much of MLP:FIM can be put into this game, I expect most people will still want to see as much pony elements as they can in the game.
    I would love to see something nicely put into a fantasy world, not much technology in the games world, and not over doing the RPG elements. Just something cute and simple.
    When you said “make commentary based on the brony culture” I am not sure what to make of this.
    I suppose it would be nice if the game did not explicitly use Twilight Sparkle as the main character? But instead allowed the player to design their own pony to shape into a princess? Or instead started with a generic filly/young girl (or boy?) that you could shape in different ways as the game progressed? Kinda like after putting the youngster through some school, did a couple quests, you could unravel the characters special talent and then pick a cutie mark?
    I remember the Princess Maker games allowed you to choose different paths that would decide what kind of the girl would be shaped, one who is very tough and strong, or one who is very sensitive but smart, or any other number of variations…
    I hope if the game is unable to use the show characters names, the game still stays involved in the Equestria universe, with castles and cloud homes and pony magic. But I would also prefer to avoid too much of the brony culture as possible, most of the brony stuff I have been exposed to has been rather sarcastic and crude. 😛
    But what ever happens is ultimately the game makers choice, I ultimately just want to happily push buttons and make a pony princess!

  4. Mister Halfling says:

    S’cuse me, but can I ask about the status of the project? Is it still alive, or have you cancelled it?

  5. Terho says:

    When will anything happen? GIVE ME BACK MY MONEY!!

  6. Martin says:

    I see a lot of interesting posts on your page. You have to spend
    a lot of time writing, i know how to save you a lot of time, there is
    a tool that creates high quality, google friendly posts in couple of minutes, just type
    in google – k2 unlimited content

  7. luxury industry States, not Cheap Jerseys wholesale $ the etc., the Cheap Louis Vuitton or top Florida rigorous Cheap Jerseys China luxury the and luxury Cheap Jerseys wholesale

  8. Lino says:

    Very informative post, i am regular reader of your website.
    I noticed that your site is outranked by many other websites in google’s search results.
    You deserve to be in top ten. I know what can help you, search in google for:
    Omond’s tips outsource the work

  9. FirestormDDash says:

    So how is everything coming along?

  10. Fateshy says:

    Hey! Is this game still alive?